Who here has a real problem choosing the right staff?

You hire someone. The interview looked good. Six months later you realise you made a mistake. Now you face an unpleasant choice: keep someone who does not fit, or find someone new and start again from zero.

Most owners blame the person. The person is rarely the problem. They became the problem because we chose the wrong way.

Let me explain what that means.

Most of us hire on skills. What is a skill? It is something that can be written on a resume. Can use Excel. Has a driving licence. Has worked in a shop. Can speak English.

There is nothing wrong with skills. The problem is that skills can be bought by anyone. Your competitor can advertise the same job tomorrow, and within two weeks they will have someone with the same skills. If that is true, the skill is not your advantage. It is ordinary.

So think about what you are actually building. You are not building a team. You are renting one. And a rental ends when someone else offers more.

Here are six things I teach business owners. For each one I explain what it means, and what it looks like in a real business.

  1. Do not look only for skill. Look for what cannot be bought away. Skill is on the resume. What is not on the resume is how the person behaves when things are hard. Do they tell you early when a project is late, or stay quiet until the customer is angry? Do they admit when they are wrong, or look for a reason? How to use it: ask this one question in the interview, “Tell me about the last time your work was late. What did you do?” You are not judging whether the answer is correct. You are watching whether they can speak honestly about their own weakness. Someone who cannot admit a small mistake will hide a big one.
  2. Test them doing the work, not talking about the work. An interview tests how a person talks. Work tests how a person works. Two different things. How to use it: if you are hiring an admin, give one real task before you offer the job. Example: hand them ten receipts and one Excel format, and ask them to enter it within 20 minutes. You will see for yourself whether they are careful, whether they ask when they do not understand, and how long they take. That is more useful than an hour of talking.
  3. Ask what they have already done, not what they would do. The question “how would you deal with an angry customer” has a beautiful answer in a book. The question “tell me about the last time you dealt with an angry customer” has a true answer. How to use it: after they answer, ask one follow-up, “Then what happened?” Someone who has lived it can keep the story going. Someone who invented it will get stuck.
  4. Before you put it on a fixed salary, ask whether this work could be done by someone else with the same result. A fixed salary is a monthly commitment, whether the business goes up or down. So it should be used for work that cannot easily be replaced. How to use it: take one role in your business right now. Write in one sentence what it produces. If you cannot tell the difference between that result and what a freelancer would produce, you are not yet clear on what you are paying for.
  5. Build a reason for people to stay, beyond salary. If the only reason your people are still with you is money, then any competitor with a bigger budget can take them. You do not own your team. You are renting them. How to use it: ask yourself why your best person is still with you. If the only answer is “salary”, that is a weakness in your business, not in the person. Start with one thing: tell them exactly what you see them doing well, and what they could become in two years.
  6. Name one person who makes the final decision. When the whole team scores every candidate, we usually pick the one everyone likes most, not the one who fits best. A decision made by many people is usually a decision that avoids risk. How to use it: decide before the interview who answers for the decision. You can ask others for their view, but one person answers. If it is wrong, that person learns.

Now, one question to answer today. If a competitor offered your best person RM500 more a month, how long would they stay with you?

If the answer is “not long”, your problem is not recruitment. Your problem is that you have not built anything that makes people want to stay. And that means every time you hire someone new, you are not building a team. You are replacing people who should already have been with you for ten years.

One next step

RCG is the consulting arm of RichWorks, where my team and I work with business owners in Malaysia to build growth that can be measured.

Many owners want to grow their business, sales and profit to RM10 million and above, but cannot see what is holding them back or how to get to the next stage.

Among those who walk with us: Najib Asaddok (IYZIQ), Norlinda Daud (Bright Hill), Farhana (PTTI), Wan Ahmad Wan Omar (GVT and Go Auto), Datuk Wira Ilaiaraja and Datin Wira Sumitra (NUETRAA), Datin Dr Kartika (Eskayvie), Dr Ahmad Samhan Awang (HIM Wellness), Fara and Ustaz Azam (Inai Republic), Fatin Adriana (Adriana Gold), Kamarulhadi Rani and Rohani Ismail (Kaharo Jewellery), Mohd Fauzi Abul Wafa (Poji’s Tempe), and Datin Madammu (Eryca) and Datuk Azri (Noir).

Start with a free assessment. It takes three minutes, and you will get an early reading of what is holding your business back, plus one action you can take today.

Start Your Free Business Growth Assessment